Superhero Birthday Party Supplies

FREE Easter Tote with $100 of Easter goodies!

Spend $100 in this collection & select a FREE Easter tote at checkout — online or in-store at our spring pop up! While quantities last!

Easter Collection
143 products

143 products

Custom Glitter Paper Banner - Pretty Day
Custom Glitter Paper Banner
Paper & Parties Boutique
from $15.39
5" Honeycomb Balls - Small (Choose your color) - Pretty Day
5" Honeycomb Balls - Small (Choose your color)
Devra Party
$2.19
8" Honeycomb Balls - Medium (Choose your color) - Pretty Day
8" Honeycomb Balls - Medium (Choose your color)
Devra Party
$3.29
21" Tissue Paper Fans - Choose Your Color - Pretty Day
21" Tissue Paper Fans - Choose Your Color
Devra Party
$5.49
Custom Gold Balloon Letter Banner - Pretty Day
Custom Gold Balloon Letter Banner
Paper & Parties
$3.29
Custom Tassel Garland DIY Kit - Pretty Day
Custom Tassel Garland DIY Kit
Paper & Parties
$3.29
Gold Birthday Number Sparklers - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Gold Birthday Number Sparklers
Meri Meri
$9.89
Gold Glitter Dipped Number Birthday Candle - Pretty Day
Gold Glitter Dipped Number Birthday Candle
Talking Tables
$5.49
Royal Blue Paper Fan Pinwheel Backdrop S1047 - Pretty Day
Royal Blue Paper Fan Pinwheel Backdrop S9104
My Mind’s Eye
$19.79
Red Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk S7012 - Pretty Day
Red Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk MA23 S0088
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$12.65
Fiesta Plastic Food Service Baskets S7058 - Pretty Day
Fiesta Plastic Food Service Baskets
Talking Tables
$13.19
Checkered Flag Racecar Napkins- 16p S1102 - Pretty Day
Checkered Flag Racecar Napkins- 16p
Beistle
$8.79
Hamptons Blue Paper Table Runner S3153 - Pretty Day
Hamptons Blue Paper Table Runner
My Mind’s Eye
$14.85
Meri Meri - Rainbow Happy Birthday Fringe Garland S1204 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri - Rainbow Happy Birthday Fringe Garland
Meri Meri
$38.49
White 10 Ft Tissue Fan Garland Bunting - Pretty Day
White 7 Ft Tissue Fan Garland Bunting
Devra Party
$10.99
Yellow Straws Eco Friendly Paper Straws S3066 - Pretty Day
Yellow Straws Eco Friendly Paper Straws
Paper & Parties Boutique
$7.69
Small Red Glossy Short Cups - 8 pack S3162 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Small Red Glossy Short Cups - 8 pack
Meri Meri
$10.99
Confetti - Black, White & Gold S4062 - Pretty Day
Confetti - Black, White & Gold
Paperboy
$7.69
Red 10 Ft Tissue Fan Garland Bunting - Pretty Day
Red 10 Ft Tissue Fan Garland Bunting
Devra Party
$12.09
Melamine Cake Stand Large- Ink Black 11.5" - Pretty Day
Melamine Cake Stand Large- Ink Black 11.5"
Joyeux Company
$64.90
Monochrome Striped and Diamond Paper Cups 8pk. - Pretty Day
Monochrome Striped and Diamond Paper Cups 8pk.
Hootyballoo by Club Green
$6.88
Black & White Signature Checker Plates Large 8pk. - Pretty Day
Black & White Signature Checker Plates Large 8pk.
Bonjour Fête
$15.94
Superhero Temporary Tattoos S1129 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Superhero Temporary Tattoos
Meri meri
$8.25
Woodland Wooden Cutlery S9239 S9240 - Pretty Day
Woodland Wooden Cutlery
Party Deco
$6.59
Superheroes Toppers 12pk. - Pretty Day
Superheroes Toppers 12pk.
Pooka Party
$7.59
Pooka Party - Superhero Small Plates (Set of 8) - Pretty Day
Superhero Small Plates 8pk.
Pooka Party
$9.89
Pooka Party - Superhero Reusable Wall Decal - Black (20 Pcs) - Pretty Day
Superhero Reusable Wall Decal - Black (20 Pcs)
Pooka Party
$10.64
Rainbow Twisted Tall Birthday Candles S3066 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Rainbow Twisted Tall Birthday Candles
Meri Meri
$18.69
Ombre Blue Birthday Candles S1083 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Ombre Blue Birthday Candles
Meri Meri
$18.69
Kpop Temporary Tattoos
Kpop Temporary Tattoos
Petit Fetti
$12.10
Bright Honeycomb Garlands 4pk S4145 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Bright Honeycomb Garlands 4pk
Meri Meri
$32.99
Gold Glitter Dipped Candles S8089 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Gold Glitter Dipped Candles
Meri Meri
$17.59
Sold Out
Superheroes Felt Masks Set of 4 - Pretty Day
Superheroes Felt Masks Set of 4
Pooka Party
$18.24
Sold Out
Large Bright Red Scalloped Edge Napkins S3005 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Large Bright Red Scalloped Edge Napkins
Meri Meri
$13.19
Sold Out
Spidey Superhero Foil Tabletop Balloon Decoration (Airfill Only) - Pretty Day
Spidey Superhero Foil Tabletop Balloon Decoration (Airfill Only)
SKS Anagram
$10.18
Sold Out
Spidey Superhero Foil Balloon - Pretty Day
Spidey Superhero Foil Balloon
anagram
$12.09
Sold Out
Cosmic Space Party Balloon Garland Kit S9237 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Cosmic Space Party Balloon Garland Kit S9327
Meri Meri
$82.49
Sold Out
Confetti - Emerald Green & Gold S2113 - Pretty Day
Confetti - Emerald Green & Gold
Paperboy
$8.46
Sold Out
Large Bright Blue Octagonal Dinner Plates S1072 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Large Bright Blue Octagonal Dinner Plates S2045
Meri meri
$18.15
Sold Out
Large Black Spikey Star Balloon Decoration S3008 - Pretty Day
Large Black Spikey Star Balloon Decoration S3008
Party Deco
$12.65
Sold Out
Meri Meri Superheroes Party Garland Banner
Meri Meri Superheroes Party Garland Banner S8031
Meri Meri
$30.79
Sold Out
Small Bright Blue Scalloped Edge Napkins S1052 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Small Bright Blue Scalloped Edge Napkins S1052
Meri Meri
$11.55
Sold Out
Golden Eco Confetti S1083 - Pretty Day
Golden Eco Confetti S0085
The Flair Exchange
$9.08
Sold Out
Comic Attack Click Pen -1 Pen S2123 - Pretty Day
Comic Attack Click Pen -1 Pen S2123
OOLY
$4.39
Sold Out
Red, White and Blue Eco Confetti S7064 - Pretty Day
Red, White and Blue Eco Confetti S7064
The Flair Exchange
$8.79
Sold Out
Black and White Fine Stripes Napkins (Set of 16) S4142 - Pretty Day
Black and White Fine Stripes Napkins (Set of 16) S4142
Pooka Party
$8.79
Sold Out
Meri Meri - Superhero Party Masks S9078 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri - Superhero Party Masks S9065
Meri meri
$23.09
Sold Out
Meri Meri Superhero Comic Bubble Balloon S9089 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Superhero Comic Bubble Balloon S9089
Meri Meri
$25.29
Sold Out
Silver Disposable Paper Party 8oz Cup- 8 pack S7154 - Pretty Day
Silver Disposable Paper Party 8oz Cup- 8 pack S7139
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$8.79
Sold Out
Spider Man Head Balloon - Pretty Day
Spider Man Head Balloon
anagram
$5.49
Sold Out
Red White and Blue Striped Eco Friendly Paper Straws S4100 - Pretty Day
Red White and Blue Striped Eco Friendly Paper Straws S4100
Paper & Parties Boutique
$7.69
Sold Out
Meri Meri Superhero Plates - Pack of 8 S9035 - Paper & Parties
Meri Meri Superhero Plates - Pack of 8 S8060
Meri Meri
$15.39
Sold Out
Meri Meri Superhero Lightning Bolt Paper Party Napkins
Meri Meri Superhero Lightning Bolt Paper Party Napkins - Pack of 16
Meri Meri
$13.75
Sold Out
Super Hero Party Backdrop Garland S0044 - Pretty Day
Super Hero Party Backdrop Garland
Ginger Ray
$10.99
Sold Out
Silver Star Garland S1044 - Pretty Day
Silver Star Garland JN23 S2108
Party Deco
$7.69
Sold Out
Classic Comic Cocktail Napkins 25pk S3085 - Pretty Day
Classic Comic Cocktail Napkins 25pk S3085
Coterie Party Supplies
$12.64
Sold Out
Red Stripe Paper Cups (x 8) S9018 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Red Stripe Paper Cups (x 8)
Meri meri
$10.99
Sold Out
Octagonal Gold Plates- Large S7028 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Octagonal Gold Plates- Large 8pk.
Meri Meri
$16.49
Sold Out
Shiny Gold Foil Short Tumbler Cups S8008 S8013 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Shiny Gold Foil Short Tumbler Cups
Meri Meri
$10.99
Sold Out
Silver Mini Banner Set: Chrome S2133 - Pretty Day
Silver Chrome Mini Banner Set
My Mind’s Eye
$10.44
Sold Out
Black & White Party Fans S5054 - Pretty Day
Black & White Party Fans JN23 S9200
My Mind’s Eye
$36.29
Sold Out
Poolside Eco Confetti S2116 - Pretty Day
Poolside Eco Confetti S2116
The Flair Exchange
$8.79
Sold Out
Poolside Tassel Garland Kit S5106 - Pretty Day
Poolside Tassel Garland Kit S5106
The Flair Exchange
$19.25