Under The Sea Party Supplies

A LITTLE HALLOWEEN TREAT, ON US!

Spend $150 and get a FREE trick-or-treat bag. Want one now? You can shop the bags separately, too.

Shop now
134 products

134 products

Blue Stripe Large Napkins (x 16) S5103 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Blue Stripe Large Napkins (x 16)
Meri Meri
$13.75
Light Blue Striped Paper Party Plate- Small - 8pk S9043 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Light Blue Striped Paper Party Plate- Small - 8pk
Meri Meri
$14.03
Sky Blue Striped Cocktail Napkins - Small S7064 - Pretty Day
Sky Blue Striped Cocktail Napkins - Small S7038
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$10.99
Sky Blue Paper Plates Small- 8pk S7063 - Pretty Day
Sky Blue Paper Plates Small- 8pk S3156
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$8.25
Sky Blue Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk S4177 - Pretty Day
Sky Blue Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk S4177
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$12.65
Mermaid Tail Paper Party Napkins S1169 - Pretty Day
Mermaid Tail Paper Party Napkins S9309
Jollity & Co. + Daydream Society
$12.09
Blue Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk S4170 - Pretty Day
Blue Paper Party Napkins- Large 20pk S0054
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$12.65
Blue Paper Party Napkins- Small 20pk S7086 - Pretty Day
Blue Paper Party Napkins- Small 20pk S7042
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$10.99
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- Blue S1189 - Pretty Day
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- Blue
Paper & Parties Boutique
$10.99
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- White S1168 - Pretty Day
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- White
Paper & Parties Boutique
$10.99
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- Green S0152 - Pretty Day
Eco-Friendly Paper Tablecloth Table Cover- Green
Paper & Parties Boutique
$10.99
Royal Blue Eco Friendly Paper Straws S7088 - Pretty Day
Royal Blue Eco Friendly Paper Straws
Paper & Parties Boutique
$7.69
Blue Foil Paper Straws 25pk - Pretty Day
Blue Foil Paper Straws 25pk
Paper & Parties Boutique
$7.69
Blue Striped Popcorn Boxes- 6pk S1099 - Pretty Day
Blue Striped Popcorn Boxes- 6pk
Party Deco
$6.59
Jumbo Balloon & Tassel Tail - White & Gold S8075 - Pretty Day
Jumbo Balloon & Tassel Tail - White & Gold
Paperboy
$43.99
Melamine Cake Stand- Wedgewood Blue - Pretty Day
Melamine Cake Stand- Wedgewood Blue
Joyeux Company
$65.99
Check It! Out of the Blue Plates - 2 Size Options - 8 Pk. - Pretty Day
Checkered Blue Plates Small- 8 Pk.
Jollity & Co. + Daydream Society
$12.65
Palisades Blue Signature Cabana Stripe Table Runner - Pretty Day
Palisades Blue Signature Cabana Stripe Table Runner
Bonjour Fête
$29.14
Light Blue Wooden Cutlery Set - Pretty Day
Light Blue Wooden Cutlery Set
Party Deco
$9.89
Mint Wooden Cutlery Set - Pretty Day
Mint Wooden Cutlery Set
Party Deco
$9.89
Bonjour Fête - SKY BLUE SIGNATURE SMALL PLATES - Pretty Day
Sky Blue Signature Plates Small 8pk.
Bonjour Fête
$14.29
Light Blue & Gold Confetti S7004 - Pretty Day
Light Blue & Gold Confetti
Paperboy
$8.79
Ombre Blue Birthday Candles S1083 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Ombre Blue Birthday Candles
Meri Meri
$18.69
Blue Stripe Small Napkins (x 16) S9071 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Blue Stripe Small Napkins (x 16)
Meri Meri
$11.55
Blue Tinsel Scallop Garland
Blue Tinsel Scallop Garland
Meri Meri
$59.39
Fresh Mint Signature Cabana Plates Large 8pk.
Fresh Mint Signature Cabana Plates Large 8pk.
Bonjour Fête
$15.68
Colorful Fringe Party Hats S9029 - Pretty Day
Colorful Fringe Party Hats 8pk.
Meri Meri
$37.39
Under the Sea Octopus Plates 8pk S3005 - Pretty Day
Under the Sea Octopus Plates 8pk
Meri Meri
$16.49
Baby Shark Jumbo Foil Balloon S4002 - Pretty Day
Baby Shark Jumbo Foil Balloon
Anagram
$10.99
Red Crab Foil Balloon 18" - Pretty Day
Red Crab Foil Balloon 18"
Anagram
$4.68
Cute Octopus Jumbo Balloon 30"
Cute Octopus Jumbo Balloon 30"
Anagram
$14.84
Axolotl Birthday Jumbo Foil Balloon 28"
Axolotl Birthday Jumbo Foil Balloon 28"
Anagram
$13.19
Gold Glitter Birthday Candles -24pk S1140 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Gold Glitter Birthday Candles -24pk
Meri Meri
$19.79
Puffer Fish Paper Plate 8 Pack - Pretty Day
Puffer Fish Paper Plate 8 Pack
Hootyballoo by Club Green
$10.99
Hootyballoo by Club Green - Hanging Starfish 4 Metres - Pretty Day
Hanging Starfish Decoration 4 Metres
Hootyballoo by Club Green
$13.19
Mermaid Tail Foil Balloon Purple
Mermaid Tail Foil Balloon Purple
Zoey Christina
$9.89
Cute Jellyfish Foil Balloon- Blue 20"
Cute Jellyfish Foil Balloon- Blue 20"
Zoey Christina
$10.99
Mermaid Tail Foil Balloons - Pink
Mermaid Tail Foil Balloons - Pink
Zoey Christina
$9.89
Mermaid Party Under the Sea Fan Set 6pk. - Pretty Day
Mermaid Party Under the Sea Fan Set 6pk.
My Mind’s Eye
$39.59
Mermaid Tail Paper Party Cups 8pk. - Pretty Day
Mermaid Tail Paper Party Cups 8pk.
My Mind’s Eye
$14.29
Meri Meri Fish Plates 8pk.
Meri Meri Fish Plates 8pk.
Meri Meri
$18.98
Under the Sea Mermaid Jumbo Banner - Pretty Day
Under the Sea Mermaid Jumbo Banner
My Mind’s Eye
$15.94
Sold Out
Meri Meri - Blue Giant Shark Balloon S2051 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri - Blue Giant Shark Balloon
Meri Meri
$24.19
Sold Out
Sea Friends Food Picks 12pk. - Pretty Day
Sea Friends Food Picks 12pk.
Hootyballoo by Club Green
$5.49
Sold Out
Meri Meri - Blue Balloon Backdrop Kit S2030 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri - Blue Balloon Backdrop Kit S1152
Meri Meri
$65.99
Sold Out
Large Shark Platter Plates S0002 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Large Shark Platter Plates
Meri meri
$17.59
Sold Out
Under The Sea Tats - 50 foil temporary tattoos - Pretty Day
Under The Sea Temporary Tattoos 50pk
Petit Fetti
$12.93
Sold Out
Mermaid Pink Pastel Seashell Foil Balloon
Mermaid Pink Pastel Seashell Foil Balloon
Zoey Christina
$5.49
Sold Out
Octopus & Shark Cupcake Kit (x 24 toppers)
Octopus & Shark Cupcake Kit (x 24 toppers)
Meri Meri
$27.49
Sold Out
Jumbo Lobster Foil Balloon
Jumbo Lobster Foil Balloon
Zoey Christina
$6.59
Sold Out
Sky Blue Paper Party Napkins- Small 20pk S4178 - Pretty Day
Sky Blue Paper Party Napkins- Small 20pk S4182
Oh Happy Day Party Shop
$10.99
Sold Out
Light Blue Striped Paper Party Plate- Large - 8pk S9060 - Pretty Day
Meri Meri Light Blue Striped Paper Party Plate- Large - 8pk
Meri Meri
$18.15
Sold Out
Jellyfish Party Bags 5 Pack
Jellyfish Party Bags 5 Pack
Hootyballoo by Club Green
$14.29
Sold Out
Blue Party Confetti S7013 - Pretty Day
Blue Party Confetti
Paperboy
$8.79